Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Indeed, but the preview functionality was very useful for deciding whether to add a particular feed.

Couldn't an XSLT + XSL stylesheet achive most of what the preview function would continue to be useful for?



You lost me at "...XSLT + XSL stylesheet..."

I've had at least 2 experiences with that particular tech, and I found it horribly over-engineered and a total PITA to work with.

On top of that, I still can't figure out exactly what problem its trying to solve, unless it purpose is job security to overpaid corporate contractors.

We have HTML5 and CSS for rendering and JSON for content, and we should just leave everything else be.


> I've had at least 2 experiences with that particular tech, and I found it horribly over-engineered and a total PITA to work with.

It's because XSL is (recursive) functional programming, and most developers fight that fact trying to write imperative XSL.

> We have HTML5 and CSS for rendering and JSON for content, and we should just leave everything else be.

Except you're not going to anything with JSON without writing Javascript code, since neither HTML or CSS do understand JSON. XSL works without a single line of Javasript and it is still supported by most browsers.


True ;) https://github.com/concerto/concerto-simple-rss/wiki/Transfo...

Probably it suffices to use regular CSS after having it converted to XHTML...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: