Wow, you're right. I tried again just now and it worked fine. In the past I tried for some time to get this setup working and was never able to do it. I don't know what I was doing wrong.
> If you specify -i or IdentityFile, the agent isn't used at all. You will have to type the keyfile password even if the key is in the agent, therefore making the agent useless.
I thought so as well, so the reply to this message surprised. I looked into it, and the following is the case on my Debian 18.04 machine running KDE:
With specifying the key through `IdentityFile` I can happily connect without a running ssh-agent. So it's true, that it can do without using the ssh-agent. But if the key has a password, it will prompt for it everytime it's used. I wouldn't phrase it "the agent isn't used at all", though, because for when ssh-agent is running, and it contains the key+password, it seems to happily use that agent, as it doesn't prompt for the password anymore.
Side note: If my understanding is correct, `IdentifyFile` lessens the need for consulting the ssh-agent as stated above, but, except from consulting it for the key password, the agent might be consulted for one more reason as well: Iterating over keys if using the specified one proved unfruitful. For this to stop, you'd have to specify `IdentitiesOnly yes` as well. But this I didn't test, so it's based on theoretical understanding only.
Edit: Oh, the last part was already explained in some other thread which branched of from this. So this post didn't actually provide some new insights, it seems.
