Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

How come the government can afford to subsidize energy if the economy can't sustain paying the "true" price for it? Where is the money coming from?


The problem with things like energy that are almost a necessity for modern life is that some individuals cannot afford it, not that "the economy" taken as a whole cannot.

Let's say 5% of Iran's GDP is spent on energy. Not sure what the number is, but whatever. A big chunk but affordable for the economy as a whole. At the market price, maybe 10% of people cannot afford to consume enough energy to meet the necessities of modern life - cooking, not freezing to death, using transportation. If you don't want these 10% of people to be shut off from modern society, you need to subsidize somehow.


It would be better to give the money to the people and they can choose to spend it on electricity or something else. Subsidizing electricity is a distortion.


Isn't that just going to bid up the prices for everything else?

Historically, subsidising electricity has worked fairly efficiently, because it wasn't possible to effectively store and re-sell or export it.


1. No

2. It has always worked the same: people arbitrage the subsidy by doing energy inefficient labor. Bitcoin mining is just a more efficient arbitrage mechanism.


Oil is where it’s coming from. Yeah you can sell as much as you can with export prices but you’ll gut your economy in the process


You're the guy that doesn't get invited to parties because you keep eating all the food because it's free, aren't you ?

All those subsidies are given under the expectation that people will behave reasonably and only use what is necessary, because it gets the country running. It's taking a hit so that your citizens can live and thrive. When you suddenly have a bunch of people running thousands of GPU for magic internet money, that is not a reasonable use of it.


Why so personal and agressive?

In my opinion it would be better to have normal energy prices and simply redistribute the money. At least it would give an incentive to use energy more efficiently




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: