Everyone judges, and with incomplete information. I don't want to cancel the guy but if my (hypothetical) daughter took an interest in him, I'd make sure she read those two public letters. It would be irresponsible to say "well it's just their words" unless those two women don't exist and it's all made up by an LLM.

At any rate, "he didn't do it" is missing the point I'm trying to make: We shouldn't professionally cancel him even if he's 100% exactly as painted.