Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You will never have as much power as Aurelius.

Why was he nevertheless a stoic?



He studied the greek classics with a mentor before he became Emperor. His Meditations reflect his study. He didn’t want to become Emperor because he viewed it as a life of strict duty and tasks that he didn’t want to do, like going on military campaigns.


Sure but why was he attracted to this philosophy, even though he had lots of power? It directly contradicts the OPs argument.

Nothing has changed in this since his time - humans will always have things they cannot change and things they can change.


His stoicism was mostly turned outward. He believed that the powerless man should accept his place below the powerful man. That submission was not shameful for the man born to submit, and that he ought to submit willingly. Stoicism does not bind the powerful, only the powerless.

I didn't even get 2 pages I to meditations before I could tell it was the philosophy of a very powerful man.


> His stoicism was mostly turned outward.

Huh? How so? In most of his writings, he's introspecting. They're basically reflections about himself and his own thoughts about things. I don't recall a passage where he's focused on anything other than internal dialogue (not saying they don't exist, but none are coming to mind).

> He believed that the powerless man should accept his place below the powerful man.

Maybe, but so did everyone else. Although, we do have Diogenes the Cynic, who heavily inspired the founding of Stoicism. Diogenes... The stories about him are quite intense. Feel free to look them up. In short, he mocked social conventions, wealth, and so-called "power".

> I didn't even get 2 pages[...]

In the first two pages, Marcus wrote about the good qualities of people throughout his life e.g. his teachers, parents, etc. Did you actually read it?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: